Main Menu


Conch Fritters Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, loaded with conch and island spices. Served with cocktail sauce 13
Dolphin Fingers Fried mahi-mahi with tartar sauce 15
Tex-Mex Rolls Homemade fried egg rolls filled with spicy chicken, corn, black beans, melted cheese, cilantro, & onion 15
Chicken Wings Ten wings tossed in mild, medium, hot, or Crazy Lady BBQ. Served with celery & blue cheese 18
Sesame Ahi Tuna* Seared sushi-grade tuna served rare with red chile soy sauce 17
Tomato Lovers’ Bruschetta Toasted baguette, Roma tomato, garlic, basil, mozzarella, and balsamic vinegar 12
Quesadilla Cheeses, peppers, onions, tomatoes, and jalapenos in a flour tortilla 12 add chicken or shrimp 16
Peel & Eat Shrimp Cooked in Caribbean spices, chilled, and served with tangy cocktail sauce ¼ lb. 8 ½ lb. 16

Fresh Green Salads

Macon & Bacon Crispy fried chicken, corn, Vidalia onions, crunchy bacon, maple pecans, romaine lettuce, and Caroline’s homemade ranch dressing 17
Boston Lettuce Wraps Grilled shrimp or chicken, carrots, coconut curry noodles, bean sprouts, and cucumber salad with peanut and spicy red chile sauces. Boston lettuce for wrapping 17
Caroline’s Salad Deluxe Turkey, ham, crisp bacon, tomatoes, hard cooked egg, cucumber, cheddar and Jack cheeses, romaine lettuce, and Caroline’s own ranch dressing 17
Bamboozled Salad Grilled, chilled, sliced chicken breast, wontons, green onions, almonds, mandarin oranges, sesame seeds, and romaine lettuce with Asian vinaigrette 17
The Bittersweet Endive, spring mix, blue cheese crumbles, candied pecans, tossed with balsamic vinaigrette 13 add chicken or shrimp 19
Yellowfin & Greens* Tuna filet served rare with toasted sesame seeds, baby lettuces, tomatoes, cucumbers, and balsamic vinaigrette 18
Caesar Salad Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, homemade croutons, and Caesar dressing 12 with chicken or shrimp 18
Southwestern Chicken Salad Grilled, chilled, sliced chicken, black beans, corn, tomatoes, tortilla strips, cheddar and jack cheeses, and romaine lettuce with lime cilantro dressing 17


Cajun Blackened Chicken Sandwich Blackened chicken with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and spicy mayo 14
Caroline’s Famous Fish Sandwich Golden brown fried fish with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce on a warm bun 17
Front Street Club Roast turkey, ham, swiss cheese, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on multi-grain bread 15
Shrimp Po’ Boy A generous serving of shrimp, fried to golden brown perfection, served with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade 17
Cuban Mix Mojo pork, ham, bacon, pickles, and yellow mustard pressed and heated 15
Dolphin Sandwich (Mahi-Mahi) Grilled and seasoned with lemon, served with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce 17
Shrimp and Bacon Club Grilled gulf shrimp, bacon, swiss cheese, tomato, lettuce, and tomato basil mayo served on multi-grain bread 17
Rev. Joe’s Burger* The BIGGEST and the BEST, with lettuce, tomato, and onion 15 add mushrooms, American, provolone, swiss, blue cheese, or cheddar cheese 2 or add crisp bacon 2.50

Caroline’s Favorites

Chicken Broccolini Sautéed chicken breast, penne pasta, and broccoli in a creamy parmesan sauce 21 add a side of bread 2
Spicy Cajun Jambalaya Shrimp, chicken, peppers, onions, Andouille sausage, and tomatoes over rice 24
Caribbean Steak* Grilled marinated skirt steak with fried plantains, black beans, and rice 28
Blackened Chicken Pasta Blackened chicken, bell peppers, and penne pasta in Cajun cream sauce 21 add a side of bread 2
Island Style Roast Pork Bowl Slow roasted pork, black beans, rice, Crazy Lady BBQ sauce, & plantain garnish 19
Fisherman’s Fresh Catch Locally caught fresh fish, grilled or blackened and served with rice and broccoli 28


Homemade Key Lime Pie 6
Cheesecake of the Day 8
The Cookie Monster 9

From the legal department…

All our food is prepared to order. Our attention to allergy food preparation is diligent and detailed.
Many items can be prepared gluten free.
From the Legal Department:
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness
especially if you have certain medical conditions.
No pipe or cigar smoking is allowed at Caroline’s.
To protect our guests, Caroline’s may decide not to serve adult beverages to persons at its sole discretion. The legal drinking age in Florida is (21); Key West is a part of Florida.
An 18% service charge may be added to parties of 6 or more.